Malaysiakini
ENBM中文TA
Sign In
Subscribe
  • LifetimeACTIVEINACTIVEEXPIRED
  • Registered on:Renews on:
    ACTIVEINACTIVEEXPIRED
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Extend Subscription
  • Settings
  • Contact Support
  • Sign Out
  • Latest
  • Videos
  • Opinions
  • Yoursay
  • Featured
  • Kini News Lab
  • KiniGuide
  • Sustainability
  • Events
  • Collab Content
  • TopTech
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • File a complaint
  • Address
Malaysiakini
Subscribe
  • Latest
  • Videos
  • Opinions
  • Yoursay
  • Featured
  • Kini News Lab
  • KiniGuide
  • Sustainability
  • Events
  • Collab Content
  • TopTech
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • File a complaint
  • Address
ENBM中文TA

      ANNOUNCEMENT

      He was the sole candidate proposed for the post during a state committee meeting.

      He was the sole candidate proposed for the post during a state committee meeting.

      The moderate Malay Muslim is a myth
      Malaysiakini
      Opinions
      The moderate Malay Muslim is a myth

      The moderate Malay Muslim is a myth

      Mariam MokhtarPublished: Feb 1, 2019 8:18 AM | Updated: Feb 1, 2019 2:01 PM

      COMMENT | This time last year, we were gripped by a culture of fear. Badmouthing the prime minister would attract the police. Publishing anything which annoyed Putrajaya would encourage the MCMC to block your website. Criticising the royals would invite mass protests and charges of sedition. We lived in a surreal world where corruption triumphed over common sense.

      Fast forward to January 2019 and “Malaysia Baru” is a comparatively freer society. We can express ourselves without the fear of the police and the dakwah squad breathing down our necks. But one thing is clear - the moderate Malay Muslims are still in hiding.

      Now, let me pop another bubble.

      The Malays who demand syariah law, who want Malay women to be seen and not heard, who want women to be covered and assume a backseat role in society are not the rural folk.

      The villagers are too busy trying to survive. Instead, the ones who demand a more Islamic society in a multicultural Malaysia are the tudung-clad Muslim women or Muslim men who are comfortable in Western attire, who converse in English, are Western educated, are well-travelled and professionals and articulate.

      The voices of "moderate" Malay Muslims are needed to help oppose the growing demand for extremist practices, like the hudud bill or the death penalty for those who quit Islam. Again, the moderates have gone into hibernation.

      They are probably afraid to be seen opposing other Muslims and risk being called heretics. We want their voices to lend support to oppose the beating and whipping of LGBTs and the violent deaths of transgenders, to criticise polygamy, child marriages and khalwat squads, and to denounce the forced conversions of the Orang Asli.

      The "moderates" keep quiet, even if they disagree. Their silence is tantamount to approval of these extremist practices. In truth, there are no "moderate" Malays. They do not exist...

      COMMENT | So where are these so-called moderate Malay Muslims?

      PAS, Umno paint May 9 as disastrous for Malay Muslims

      PAS, Umno paint May 9 as disastrous for Malay Muslims

      How lucky! Malay Muslims don’t need to think

      How lucky! Malay Muslims don’t need to think

      I want to  be PM – to end the hate of LGBTs

      I want to be PM – to end the hate of LGBTs

      Law expert: Malaysia neither secular nor Islamic state

      Law expert: Malaysia neither secular nor Islamic state

      • comments14
      • facebook
      • whatsapp
      • x
      • comments14
      • facebook
      • whatsapp
      • x
      Related reports4

      PAS, Umno paint May 9 as disastrous for Malay Muslims

      21-01-2019

      How lucky! Malay Muslims don’t need to think

      16-02-2017

      I want to be PM – to end the hate of LGBTs

      27-09-2018

      Law expert: Malaysia neither secular nor Islamic state

      25-01-2019
      View Comments14

      Trust you, Mariam to call a spade, a spade. Yes, Malaysian society will not appear so intolerant if more CC Malays will speak up against the extremists actions of 'taliban' islamists in PAS and UMNO.

      Dr David Ting05:50 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      I live in the Malay heartland of Kelantan. I take my Rottweiler dog for his countryside walk every Friday in the padi-fields and kampongs. Everywhere we go the Malays are intrigued by him; we are never troubled by anyone. Instead they crowd around my car to have a good look and him. Their natural curiosity and enthusiasm for animals are apparent and intact. That is the Malaysia that I hope will never change, and my experience with the rural kampung folks give me hope that better sense will prevail.

      Wilson Teo12:00 PM, 01 Feb 2019

      "In Malaysia, politicians control the Malay mind and stupefy the Malays by removing their ability to think. They can then divide the nation and remain in power."....basically sums up the reality in Malaysia.

      Jasmine Marie11:40 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Comment0

      By posting a comment, you agree to our Commenting Terms and Conditions as stipulated in full here.

      Do's and don'ts when posting comments in Malaysiakini

      TERMS & CONDITIONS

      Foul language, profanity, vulgarity, slanderous, personal attack, threatening, sexually-orientated comments or the use of any method of communication that may violate any law or create needless unpleasantness will not be tolerated. Antisocial behaviour such as "spamming" and "trolling" will be suspended. Violators run the risk of also being blocked permanently.

      REPORT VIOLATORS

      Please use the report feature that is available below each comment to flag offending comments for our moderators to take action. Do not take matters in your own hands to avoid unpleasant and unnecessary exchanges that may result in your own suspension or ban.

      Subscriber-only space:

      Are you a subscriber?

      Sign In

      Not yet a subscriber?

      Subscribe

      600 characters remaining

      Trust you, Mariam to call a spade, a spade. Yes, Malaysian society will not appear so intolerant if more CC Malays will speak up against the extremists actions of 'taliban' islamists in PAS and UMNO.

      Dr David Ting05:50 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      I live in the Malay heartland of Kelantan. I take my Rottweiler dog for his countryside walk every Friday in the padi-fields and kampongs. Everywhere we go the Malays are intrigued by him; we are never troubled by anyone. Instead they crowd around my car to have a good look and him. Their natural curiosity and enthusiasm for animals are apparent and intact. That is the Malaysia that I hope will never change, and my experience with the rural kampung folks give me hope that better sense will prevail.

      Wilson Teo12:00 PM, 01 Feb 2019

      "In Malaysia, politicians control the Malay mind and stupefy the Malays by removing their ability to think. They can then divide the nation and remain in power."....basically sums up the reality in Malaysia.

      Jasmine Marie11:40 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Yes, Mariam. Correct!! Didn't Anwar and Rafizi both were targeting 'super liberals'? They couldn't and can't win the logical arguments against the kind of creeping Wahhabi Islam that is being practised in Malaysia these days. Why can't Malay women freely NOT wear the tudung? Why can't they wear their sarong kebaya? Why can't the Kelantan folks enjoy Wayang Kulit without suspicions that they are somehow playing with Hindu spirits. Why is there a freaking bodoh fatwa against doing yoga? P Ramlee and his Melayu generation were FREE. These days, they are Arab wannabes. And some of them are willing to be suicide bombers. So, why would any right-minded non-Melayu Malaysians not want to run away from this toxic Islamic environment?

      sururi katmin11:36 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      MM, race is race, religion is religion, they are different, but happened to be the "same" here.. the middle easterner etc. are not malays but their teaching is to plant seeds in all corners of the world, then demand all sorts of "rights", then call the kind hearted hosts kaafir; the westerners were magnanimous but are now saddled with all sorts of issues now; kudos to Japanese, South Koreans for not receiving the potentially toxic, explosivve seeds.. any wonder why China has to reign in big time the 'righteous' before things get out of hand?

      Ken Li11:26 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Malays are indeed very conscious of how tenuous these tags can be. Many do not wish to be self assigned or publicly proclaimed baton carriers of the moderates vs fundamentalists polemics. Whilst many are hesistant to turn into polemicists on the subject matter, they are acutely aware of the devasting consequences if the balance is tipped heavily on one side. Truth be told, many expect the mature Muslim voices in leadership not to be so spiritless in countering the virulent fundamentalist tendencies in the community. That perhaps has been the clearest indication of their preference to follow the centrist path. But asking the Malays to stand on soap boxes to denouce their sacred cows maybe a bridge too far.

      Md Jaber11:19 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      The T-shirt with the caption " Apa Malu bosku" speaks volumn about the moral standing of the Malay supremist. Najib and gang were so proud of that. This message shows that being a thief or a robber is nothing to be ashamed of. Wonder if it's part of the religious education instilled into these youths from young. PH should be creative and add " Jadi pencuri, apa malu bosku"

      Ming Fei Lim11:17 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      You hit the nail in the head, call a spade a spade. No core changes will ever take place until the "moderates", ( if they do in fact exist, if at all), become vocal enough and in sufficient numbers to disavow political models and operating mechanisms determined by concepts of ketuanan, .consistently subjected to implementation of policies prescribed, defined by what the proponents want and not what the people need. This political model will always be the basics that will never, ever change. |Let not delude ourselves, naive as we may be.!!!

      TAI CHUN WAH11:09 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      But Mariam, if we non-Malays try to voice our opinion on certain "sensitive" matters, the Malay Muslim fanatics will jump up and down, froth at their mouths, bay for our blood and tell us "jangan cabar......, jangan masuk campur......., ini bukan hal non-Muslim, etc etc etc!"

      Jimmy Lim10:46 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Well said Mariam. This snapshot of the Malay mind is the consequence of 60 years of state led propaganda to control the Malay mind and psyche. Your last paragraph ""If you are Malay, do not allow yourself to be manipulated by people with a political agenda. If you are non-Malay, don't use the cop-out, "I do not wish to interfere in another religion."" is key. Change must start today.

      Huzaimi Sabri10:44 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Well, thank you Mariam, for a candid disclosure of the Malays’ psyche. Thank you for being able to see their faults and is not apologetic about it. If you may, perhaps this come about as a result of the racial mix that we have in Malaysia, a confluence of people from opposite poles. If we are just consisting of the Polynesians, probably assimilation was easier to mask the cultural differences and therefore homogeneity easily achieved so that we could only squabble over the colours of our neighbour carpets instead of whether they were Chinese, Indians or Christians. You said rightly, and this is important, that the Malay mentality that we have today was the result of our government policy. There is no two ways about it. How could Malays living overseas have no problem with the images of pigs, dogs and crosses, while here we would go on a stampede if those should be exhibited conspicuously in public? The type of our country will produce the type of our people. In today’ generation, where we are getting Gen Z, this is something that Harapan can change and reform, lest we will be left behind in the global world, which we only have ourselves to be blamed for.

      Ada Yang10:30 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Mariam is spot-on. Khafir Pendatang who argues that the problem is pervasive and insoluble also has good points. So Malaysia is like a pot boiling merrily on the fire for 61 years where too much salt or the wrong ingredients or something else was done wrong. In 1969, someone kicked the pot off and then they added more pepper called bumi trying to correct everything. It failed again Then on May 9th 2018, they lifted the pot off, put it down, had Eminent Persons examine it carefully for 100 days. But then put it back basically the same ingredients. Unchanged. Unchangeable? Now it looks like the new cooks have no good idea or no blardey guts to make substantive changes. What will wake up those moderate Malays and their non-Malay counterparts? A limited nuclear war? An alien invasion? What does it take to get us all out of our comfort zone? Because we are all quite, quite comfortable, aren't we? And maybe that right there is the problem.

      Dahari Jol09:40 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Mariam is spot-on. Kafir Pendatang who argues that the problem is pervasive and insoluble also has good points. So Malaysia is like a pot boiling merrily on the fire for 61 years where too much salt or the wrong ingredients or something else was done wrong. In 1969, someone kicked the pot off and then they added more pepper called bum# trying to correct everything. It failed again Then on May 9th 2018, they lifted the pot off, put it down, had Eminent Persons examine it carefully for 100 days. But then put it back basically the same ingredients. Unchanged. Unchangeable? Now it looks like the new cooks have no good idea or no blardey guts to make substantive changes. What will wake up those moderate Malays and their non-Malay counterparts? A limited nuclear war? An alien invasion? What does it take to get us all out of our comfort zone? Because we are all quite, quite comfortable, aren't we? And maybe that right there is the problem.

      Dahari Jol09:39 AM, 01 Feb 2019

      Wow Mariam Mokhtar,that was the best article which is the truth about what is happening in Malaysia and the picture of pigs,dogs and the litted Cross are truly a litmus test for CC Muslims,who are seen but not heard.Within a walking distance acoss to Woidlands,Singapore,the CNY celebration at Shopping Malls around the cities,one find the Zodiac sign of decorated pigs,with various designs and colour decorating the mall and the enlightened Muslims are joining in the CNY festival,which speaks volume of the Island racial and religious tolerance.In Malaysia and as.long as UMNO and PAS parties are around;you can forget about racial and religious tolerance,which their rabble-rousers will stir up unrest amongs various races and the latest issue was the Penang litted Cross.

      KH Chua09:10 AM, 01 Feb 2019
      mk-logo
      • whatsapp
      • telegram
      • youtube
      • facebook
      • x
      • instagram
      • tiktok
      • linkedin
      • About Us
      • Our Team
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Service
      • Advertise with Us
      • Careers
      • Archive
      • Digital Network
      • KiniTV
      • FG Media
      • RSS Feeds
      • News
      • Opinion
      • Letters
      Contact Editorial
      envelopeeditor@malaysiakini.com
      Contact Subscription/Tech Support
      telephone+6017-323 0707
      envelopesubscribe@malaysiakini.com
      • Advertising
      • advertise@malaysiakini.com
      • advertise@fgmedia.my
      Mkini Dotcom Sdn Bhd
      (199901014818 / 489718-U)No. 9, Jalan 51/205A, Off Jalan Tandang, 46050 Petaling Jaya, Selangor
      Contact Editorial
      envelopeeditor@malaysiakini.com
      Contact Subscription/Tech Support
      telephone+603-7770 0017
      envelopesubscribe@malaysiakini.com
      @Kini
      No. 9, Jalan 51/205A, Off Jalan Tandang, 46050 Petaling Jaya, Selangor